Re: [sig-policy]Proposals for Address Policy SIG at APNIC15
> Review Policy. You can find them at:
>
> http://www.apnic.net/meetings/15/sigs/policy/index.html
have you looked at, for instance, the so-called proposal for
signing the root zone at that url? it says
An Interim Scheme for Signing the Public DNS Root, Johan Ihren,
Autonomica
Synopsis
This is a proposal for transitioning from an unsigned DNS root
to a signed root where the data will be signed by DNSSEC
signatures.
The underlying reason for signing the root is to be able to
provide a more secure DNS hierarchy, where it is possible to
distinguish false answers from correct answers. For the special
case of the DNS root zone, an interim scheme is proposed. This
scheme is mostly aimed at securing the root zone itself for
technical and operational reasons, and to give operational
experience of DNSSEC.
that's the whole thing. it has zero technical content. and, in
fact, johan's proposal is being discussed in the ietf and some good
folk feel it has some way to go before it is ready to be discussed
in the dns and security communities, let alone be cast as policy in
a meeting of ip address management folk from isps in asia or
anywhere else.
and then we get to the 'proposal' for the doc review and policy
process. all it says is
Doc Review and Policy Processes Anne Lord, Gerard Ross, APNIC
Secretariat
Synopsis
This proposal is split into two parts. One part proposes
modifications to the existing Document Review Policy to align
it more closely to the processes and outcomes of consensus
decisions that emerge from the APNIC Open Policy Meeting.
The existing Policy making processes have been evolving for
some time to become more structured and organised.
This agenda item is a review of those processes to see if they
meet the needs of the Internet community in the Asia Pacific.
do you really think this is a proposal? and what do you intend to
do in taipei based on this 'proposal'?
oh, it does have a link to the existing process of which i presume
all this is an example. QED.
randy