Re: [sig-policy] prop-086: Global policy for IPv4 allocations by the IAN
> I agree with the sentiment expressed by several folks yesterday. We (the
> community) need to work out a way of making prop-069 (as it was here)
> fly in the ARIN region. It was approved in the other 4 RIR regions.
Philip
Prop-069 had two aspects: establishing an IANA pool for returned space,
and making return of space to the IANA mandatory. It's possible for all
of the RIRs to agree on the former point without "meddling" in each others
policy, it does not appear possible to reconcile on the latter point at
this time.
i.e. If mandatory return is a requirement in any region, then one would
expect prop-086 (which lacks such in my reading) to suffer a similar fate
as prop-069.
/John
John Curran
President and CEO
ARIN