Re: [sig-nir] Forming WG to discuss about NIR Fee
To begin with, Thank Maemura for your good suggestion.
About Maemura's suggestion, my opinion is as belows.
> NIR Colleagues,
>
> Regarding the NIR Fee, JPNIC IP Department has just had a
> brief discussion.
>
> One of the way to look for a reasonable fee schedule is
> raising some example schedules and/or models and then
> applying current facts to verify if it is reasonable.
Yes, sure.
> We notice that for verification we need all figures from
> per address fee amount, number of members and total address
> space of all NIRs'. but they are of course not disclosed.
I agree with this.And as I think, we need the information on budget status
of each NIR.
That is to say, we should consider NIR's operation cost of each NIR
in order to check how much APNIC fee affect NIR's financial status under
their own economic situation.
> I think in this case we should form a *closed* working group
> which contains all NIRs and APNIC Secretariat to share such
> closed data.
In this context, I also have the same idea with JPNIC. We should form
WG which will be participated from all NIRs & APNIC.
I also expect another good ideas from other NIRs.
Sincerely yours,
Yong Wan Ju