Thank you Akinori for your suggestion. I attach a document that I have submitted to the CRISP team for its consideration and to assist in discussions, possibly at the teleconference scheduled to take place this evening (Asia Pacific time). This document summarises the proposals made by APNIC, RIPE NCC and LACNIC for their respective community's consideration. It also discusses a possible way of consolidating all three current proposals. This will accommodate the needs and concerns of these regions. ARIN staff have indicated that they see no objection to this proposal. AFRINIC staff have also indicated in discussions that they agree with this proposed way forward. Finally - a reminder. If you would like to listen in to the discussions of the CRISP team this evening, it will occur at 13:00 UTC. This will be (by way of a general guide only): 18:30 in Delhi 21:00 in Beijing and Singapore 22:00 in Tokyo 23:00 in Brisbane 02:00 in Auckland (next day) Call details have been posted separately. Craig On 10/12/2014 2:28 pm, "MAEMURA Akinori" <maem@nic.ad.jp> wrote: >Craig, > >Thank you very much for sharing the first CRISP Team teleconf. >It is great to hear that Izumi has elected to the Chair position. > >It's very aggressive for CRISP Team to develop the proposal in that short >period. > >While the CRISP confcall is open to everybody as you said, having the >community synchronized is very important. Hope you or other CRISP >members will do it. > >BTW, I think it good to have the comparison of proposal situations of >five RIRs. Do you have such material? If so it must be very helpful for >the community. > > >Thank you! > >Akinori > > > >At Wed, 10 Dec 2014 01:01:31 +0000 >In message <D0ADE699.62DF%craig@apnic.net> > "[IANAxfer@apnic] Update on CRISP (Consolidated RIR IANA >StewardshipProposal Team)" > "Craig Ng <craig@apnic.net>" wrote: > >| >| >| The CRISP team got together for the first time at midnight last night >(Melbourne time), via a Webex teleconference. >| >| All 15 members of the CRISP team were present on the call, and there >was enthusiastic participation by everyone. In addition, there were more >than 10 non-CRISP observers in attendance. Under the CRISP charter, all >CRISP teleconferences are open to anyone who would like to listen to the >CRISP team discussions (as silent observers). The next scheduled CRISP >teleconference will occur on 11 December at 13:00 UTC, and I will post >dial-in and Webex details as soon as this information is available. >| >| At the first teleconference, the voting members of the CRISP team >elected Izumi Okutani (APNIC region) as the Chair, and Alan Barrett >(AFRINIC region) as the Vice-chair of the CRISP team. Izumi did a >fantastic job and very ably chaired the remainder of the teleconference >last night. >| >| Last night, the team discussed its proposed working methodology. There >will be a teleconference twice weekly in the period leading up to the end >of the year, before the Christmas/New Year break. During this period, the >team agreed on an aggressive and ambitious timetable to produce a first >draft response to the NTIA Request for Proposal by next week, to elicit >public and community comments. The team expects to produce a second draft >response during the first week in January 2015. The final submission to >the ICG is due on 15 January 2015. The team will work by rough consensus, >except that an 8 out of 10 vote of the voting members will be required to >approve the final draft submission. >| >| Andrei Robachevsky (RIPE NCC region), Michael Abejuela (ARIN region), >Esteban Lescano (LACNIC region) and I have volunteered to work on the >first draft of the response before the next scheduled teleconference >(that is, within the next 24 hours!). >| >| I will give you more updates when there are new developments. >| >| Craig >| (Appointed APNIC staff member to the CRISP team) >| >| ** The CRISP charter is available here: ><https://www.nro.net/nro-and-internet-governance/iana-oversight/consolidat >ed-rir-iana-stewardship-proposal-team-crisp-team> >| >| >| _______________________________________________________ >| Craig Ng >| General Counsel, APNIC >| e: craig@apnic.net >| p: +61 7 3858 3152 >| m: +61 416 052 022 >| www.apnic.net >| _______________________________________________________ >| >| Join the conversation: https://blog.apnic.net/ >| _______________________________________________________ >| >| >| >| >| _______________________________________________ >| IANAxfer mailing list >| IANAxfer@apnic.net >| http://mailman.apnic.net/mailman/listinfo/ianaxfer >| >| >|
Attachment:
Summary of RIR proposals.pdf
Description: Adobe PDF document
Attachment:
smime.p7s
Description: S/MIME cryptographic signature