Re: [apnic-talk] IANA Globalization Progress

    • To: Tony Smith <tony at apnic dot net>
    • Subject: Re: [apnic-talk] IANA Globalization Progress
    • From: Naresh Ajwani <ajwaninaresh at gmail dot com>
    • Date: Fri, 21 Mar 2014 20:12:51 +0530
    • Cc: apnic-talk at lists dot apnic dot net
    • Delivered-to: apnic-talk at mailman dot apnic dot net
    • Dkim-signature: v=1; a=rsa-sha256; c=relaxed/relaxed;; s=20120113; h=mime-version:in-reply-to:references:date:message-id:subject:from:to :cc:content-type; bh=PPIMrUVimGtpG2i+ClE2BfQSST6nOVeZAj7LWYDDnB4=; b=M8PqCrFWHWLUhlH4r/gwnYHAVpb3UVfmvf7XaasF865+jDW6aNYKeqYfaV8UKnMC2O ma9RBme/A++eMSVfuWZ17NAfaHgh2hVNYIANDxnl5B6UBDe/rjGTk2MYNdoqqMpkgaoZ 6Q22oz/VFffjiOj+ngLcVRqJjjw7yZpcvpZhMRqtE8Gkq/y2i6kivHGqQgBJCzhcatC3 qnm+Na6MJ1JmgsvevFF3Zrwm+c/5bHMEamMRfRBBQa3BMRlmBBgA7gro2rCUAHlqFw2j 8mBBVUfsrnfue2RllcqjGO+h0aBUUidVeeUIz8Z9jn43BKNGZKYl2meb0he+Y1Oqjoyf JjVA==
    • In-reply-to: <CF49D2B1.7DEE%tony at apnic dot net>
    • List-archive: <>
    • List-help: <>
    • List-id: General discussions on APNIC <>
    • List-post: <>
    • List-subscribe: <>, <>
    • List-unsubscribe: <>, <>
      • New News on IANA Globalisation-Apologise for duplication,  if any.

        Important Corrections to General Inaccuracies and Misconceptions Regarding U.S. Announcement and IANA Functions

        by Fadi Chehadé on March 20, 2014

        On Friday, March 14 the U.S. Government announced its intention to transition its stewardship responsibilities of the Internet Assigned Numbers Authority (IANA) Functions to the global multistakeholder community—a key component of the Internet ecosystem. The IANA Functions are the Internet’s technical identifiers, specifically, the top-level domain names of the Domain Name System, IP addresses, and protocol parameter registries.

        The Internet is expanding at an explosive pace. But as it grows, we must ensure that it continues to promote choice and competition, drive innovation and infuse development across the globe. The Internet is a global resource and all stakeholders deserve a voice in its governance.

        Unfortunately, some critics of the U.S. Government’s announcement have begun to speculate and report through the media a number of inaccurate arguments. I would like to correct the record on some important claims.

        The announcement is NOT a final decision to surrender control of the Internet.

        On Friday, the U.S. government asked the global community to develop a proposal for transferring its stewardship of the IANA Functions. The government was not announcing a new law, rather initiating an inclusive, global discussion. The government also set clear boundaries for that discussion, including a very clear statement that it will not release control of these functions to any government-led or inter-governmental organization solution.

        Instead, ICANN will lead a transparent dialogue among governments, the private sector, and civil society to determine the transition process and establish a governing body that is globally accountable. This process ensures each of the Internet’s diverse stakeholders has a voice in its governance.

        In addition, the U.S. government has made it clear that the transition proposal must address the following four principles:

        Support and enhance the multistakeholder model
        Maintain the security, stability and resiliency of the Internet DNS
        Meet the needs and expectation of the global customers and partners of the IANA services
        Maintain the openness of the Internet
        In other words, any proposal that affects the openness of the Internet and its multistakeholder governance will be rejected.

        The announcement is NOT a response to disclosures by Edward Snowden about the National Security Agency and its policies.

        One media report claims ICANN lobbied the U.S.Government to relinquish its oversight “using the Snowden leaks as a lever.” This couldn’t be further from the truth. The government first envisioned this transfer when it began contracting with ICANN in 1998. For the past 16 years, ICANN has protected the open Internet with increasing operational excellence – itself accountable to the global community. The March 14 announcement was the final step down a path paved years ago.

        The announcement will NOT lead to a division of the Internet into smaller, less technically resilient pieces.

         ”A digital Iron Curtain” will not be imposed resulting from this announcement. An opinion piece in The Wall Street Journal claims that by stepping back, the United States will divide “425,000 global routes of the Internet into less technically resilient pieces.” In fact, the exact opposite is true.

        The March 14 announcement is an important step toward preserving and protecting the open Internet. U.S. oversight will not be usurped by authoritarian governments eager to censor free speech – or by any other inter-governmental institution. Instead, a globally accountable, multistakeholder governing body will ensure the Internet continues to promote the free exchange of ideas, propel innovation and drive economic development.

        The announcement transfers stewardship of an administrative and clerical function. ICANN does NOT serve a policing function in the Internet ecosystem.

        Let me be clear, ICANN coordinates one technical component of the Internet ecosystem – the names, numbers and protocol parameters of the Internet. ICANN does not control content on the Internet. ICANN has no role relating to Internet content and cannot enact Internet censorship.

        These technical components of the Internet have been working well for nearly two decades underneath a multistakeholder process with the U.S. government holding a stewardship role. In reality, ICANN has successfully administered the IANA Functions with increasing autonomy for the past 16 years and this announcement will not alter its commitment to the security and stability of the Internet’s Domain Name System.

        The announcement will NOT affect the billions who use the Internet every day.

        Some have speculated through the media that the U.S. announcement will “put the open Internet at risk” for everyday users. This concern is not rooted in reality. The transition of stewardship will not affect the functionality of the Internet.  The coordination of the IANA functions will continue unchanged. The announcement reinforces the principles that the Internet belongs to everyone and is responsible to everyone.

        Instead of politicizing the debate over the U.S. Government’s decision to transition stewardship of the Internet’s technical functions, let’s move forward with the discussion we need to have – how to engage in the necessary discussion to develop an effective transition process, one that continues to ensure an open Internet that belongs to everyone.


        Regards & best wishes

        Naresh Ajwani

        On 15 Mar 2014 05:20, "Tony Smith" <tony at apnic dot net> wrote:
        Hi everyone

        There's been some significant news today with the US Government stating
        that it is ready to transfer its stewardship of important Internet
        technical functions to the global Internet community.

        The US Government's current responsibilities to be transitioned include
        its role as the historic steward of the unique identifiers registries for
        Domain names, IP addresses, and protocol parameters.

        The leaders of the Internet technical community have welcomed this
        announcement - the statement is below.

        The first public discussions to develop the process for this transition
        will take place in Singapore at ICANN 49 (March 23-27).   We strongly
        encourage the Asia Pacific community to get involved in these very
        important discussions and to have your say.

        More information on the Singapore meeting is available here:

        Best wishes


        Internet Technical Leaders Welcome IANA Globalization Progress

        The leaders of the Internet technical organizations responsible for
        coordination of the Internet infrastructure (IETF, IAB, RIRs, ccTLD ROs,
        ICANN, ISOC, and W3C), welcome the US Government’s announcement of the
        suggested changes related to the IANA functions contract.

        The roles on policy development processes of the Internet technical
        organizations and ICANN's role as administrator of the IANA functions,
        remain unchanged.

        The transition of the US Government stewardship has been envisaged since
        the early days of IANA functions contract. This transition is now
        feasible due to the maturity of the Internet technical organizations
        involved in performing their respective roles related to the IANA
        functions, and ICANN will facilitate a global, multi-stakeholder process
        to plan for the transition.

        The strength and stability of the IANA functions within the above
        organizations (which make up the Internet technical community) are
        critical to the operation of the Internet. The processes around the IANA
        functions have always been carefully specified in the communities that
        our organizations represent. The IANA functions are faithfully
        administered by ICANN. We are committed to continuing our proven,
        community-driven processes as we engage in this transition. Our
        communities are already considering proposals to progress the

        Our organizations are committed to open and transparent
        multi-stakeholder processes. We are also committed to further
        strengthening our processes and agreements related to the IANA
        functions, and to building on the existing organizations and their
        roles. The Internet technical community is strong enough to continue its
        role, while assuming the stewardship function as it transitions from the
        US Government.

        Participating Leaders

        • Adiel A. Akplogan, CEO African Network Information Center (AFRINIC)

        • Barrack Otieno, Manager, The African Top Level Domains Organization

        • Paul Wilson, Director General Asia-Pacific Network Information Centre

        • Don Hollander, General Manager Asia Pacific Top Level Domain
        Association (APTLD)

        • John Curran, CEO American Registry for Internet Numbers (ARIN)

        • Peter Van Roste, General Manager, Council for European National Top
        Level Domain Registries (CENTR)

        • Russ Housley, Chair Internet Architecture Board (IAB)

        • Fadi Chehadé, President and CEO Internet Corporation for Assigned
        Names and Numbers (ICANN)

        • Jari Arkko, Chair Internet Engineering Task Force (IETF)

        • Kathy Brown, President and CEO Internet Society (ISOC)

        • Raúl Echeberría, CEO Latin America and Caribbean Internet Addresses
        Registry (LACNIC)

        • Carolina Aguerre, General Manager, Latin American and Caribbean TLD
        Association (LACTLD)

        • Axel Pawlik, Managing Director Réseaux IP Européens Network
        Coordination Centre (RIPE NCC)

        • Jeff Jaffe, CEO World Wide Web Consortium (W3C)

        apnic-talk mailing list
        apnic-talk at lists dot apnic dot net