RE: [Wg-ipv6-guide] (ToC11) Database Registration

["YongWanJu" <ywju@nic.or.kr>]

Dear Izumi, 

> > This is Yong Wan Ju at KRNIC. 
> > I am also not sure why do you limit DB access to IPv4 Internet.
> > And as you already know, DB data have managed hierachially based on 
> > allocation & assignment of management system. 
> > But we have experienced some difficulties having data newly in 
> IPv4, so in
> > this context, we had better think about alternative idea in 
> IPv6 to keep 
> > whoisv6 data updated. 
> > 
> > For example, in the case of NIRs, NIR had better take the 
> responsiblity for
> > this and implement the mirroring system between RIR & NIR. 
> > (As I know, even for IPv4, a few of NIRs have used the same way.)
> > 
> > For clear registration, how about describing the way like this ? 
> Do you mean that we shouldn't restrict the database registrations to
> RIRs, i.e, NIRs database should also be used for the registrations?
> If yes, I agree with you.

Yes, that is what i means. 

> I may be missing your point, and in that case, could you please kindly
> explain it again? 

Though there are some difference between NIRs, the evident point is that
NIRs should run their own DB for registration and that is very useful for
RIRs whois service with correct information. 
For clear whois service or management on IPv6 address, I think we had better 
make the way of DB registration clear in early stage consistent with NIR 
Operational Guideline or something.  

Now I have to go outside for another important meeting, if someone have other comments
and unclear points, please let me know then I will reply next week. 

Sincerely yours, 

Yong Wan Ju