Re: New draft of NIR criteria document

["Byung-Kyu Kim" <bkkim@nic.or.kr>]

So far, ccTLDs have been recognized by the contry-code on ISO3166.
Most of ccTLDs are in different situations under the Government.
ccTLDs are still discussing on the Government envolvements.

On Paul's document, I am not quite sure about "equivalent" endorsement.
We may need more explains on the term. If it is not related the relavent
Government, then what will be the "equivalent" ?

1.1      Endorsement of NIR

The selection of a particular organisation to act as NIR must be made at a
"national" level within the country or economy concerned, namely by explicit
Government or equivalent endorsement. This endorsement need to be expressed
formally in order for a new NIR to be recognised by APNIC.


Sincerely,

ByungKyu Kim


----- Original Message -----
From: "MAEMURA Akinori" <maem@maem.org>
To: <pwilson@apnic.net>; <nir-discuss@lists.apnic.net>
Sent: Tuesday, August 13, 2002 5:24 PM
Subject: Re: New draft of NIR criteria document


> Thanks Paul for this draft.
>
> Folks, please present your comments on this draft onto this
> mailing list.
>
>
> The highlight of this draft would be these two points and
> I personally think them reasonable.
>
>  + Executive Counsil takes the responsibility for the
> recognition of a new NIR
>
>   -> AMM approval is too heavy
>
>
>  + A new NIR must be endorsed by Government
>
>   -> similar to ccTLD delegation.
>
>
>
> looking forward to your active input to here.
>
>
> Regards,
> -----
> MAEMURA Akinori                Director, JPNIC IP Department
>                               maem@nic.ad.jp , maem@maem.org
>
>
> In message <63B9746D4A92BF498D78584958F537E302AE12@lotus.exchange>
>    "New draft of NIR criteria document"
>    ""Paul Wilson" <pwilson@apnic.net>" wrote:
>
> | Dear NIR colleagues,
> |
> | Attached is a new redraft of the criteria for recognition of NIRs, for
> | consideration during the next NIR meeting.   It is a draft only - so
> | please feel free to post your feedback and any criticisms or comments
> | before the meeting.
> |
> | Thanks and best regards,
> |
> | Paul Wilson
> | APNIC
> |
>
>
> -----
> MAEMURA Akinori                Director, JPNIC IP Department
>                               maem@nic.ad.jp , maem@maem.org
>
>
>