Re: [hostmaster-staff] Renaming - NIR meeting to NIR SIG

[MAEMURA Akinori <maem@maem.org>]

Son,

Thanks you your comment.  It was originally Anne's proposal 
and I found NIR Meeting is held just like other SIGs - 
Policy SIG, Routing SIG, IPv6 SIG, in terms of its openness,
calling for presentation and focusing a certain portion of
interest.  Now I think we don't need a special naming for
NIR's one.  Does it make sense?


Regards,
Akinori



In message <Pine.UW2.4.10.10112111410310.9733-100000@hadrian>
   "Re: [hostmaster-staff] Renaming - NIR meeting to NIR SIG"
   "John Tran <john@apnic.net>" wrote:

| 
| Hi Maemura-san,
| 
| Thank you for being a proactive chairman but I am not clear on the reason
| why do you wish to convert the NIR meeting to become a SIG. Based on my
| knowledge, please correct me if I am wrong, the SIG is a group of people
| come together as a working group to find a solution to a problem or issue
| then when the solution is found the group will desolve. An example of such
| group is the cable modem SIG, which is now does not exist because this
| group had produced a policy for cable Modem. Where as NIR meeting, it was
| original set up to allow NIRs and APNIC come together and discuss issues
| in the AP that could affect both APNIC and NIRs as a whole. As such I
| believe that the NIR meeting should be an ongoing process or do you wish
| to make this meeting less frequent?
| 
| son
| 
| 
| On Tue, 11 Dec 2001, MAEMURA Akinori wrote:
| 
| > Folks,
| > 
| > I was proposed renaming NIR meeting to NIR SIG.
| > The point is that NIR Meeting is now fully open to any 
| > parties and no significant difference from other SIGs.
| > 
| > I, as the chair, have no objection and think that is much 
| > convenient for meeting operations so I'd like to accept this
| > proposal if you agree.
| > 
| > 
| > Please present your opinion regardless positive/supporting
| > or negative/objection, to this list.  Thanks in advance.
| > 
| > 
| > Regards,
| > -----
| > MAEMURA Akinori               JPNIC IP Address Working Group
| > 
| > *    Mailing List: hostmaster-staff                                    *
| > *    Handled by majordomo@staff.apnic.net                              *
| > 
| 
|